Wednesday, September 30, 2009

Extree! Extree! Read All About It

We have been showing our kids a ton of musicals. And I mean tons. It started in January, when I put on Joseph and the Technicolor Dreamcoat and Elijah refused to listen to it. So I started renting them. I have rented a lot of them. And thought the course of these weekly viewings I learned a couple of things.

1.) My girls LOVE the musicals.
2.) Newsies was panned at the Box office.

Newsies is one of my favorite movies of all time. No joke. I love the movie. And I was stunned that it did so badly. Of course, keep in mind that it was made by the same guy who later made the "High School Musical" series of movies. And Newsies was supposed to have the same effect that" High School Musical" does today. But it didn't. It was, at the time, Disney's biggest disappointment of all time. WOW. Further keep in mind that I was a teenie bopper at the time.

So we searched online for reviews of the movie, because I just couldn't believe it did so badly. And the reviews were scathing. HORRIBLE. It was called "Howard the Newsies" by one illustrious critic, comparing it to "Howard the Duck" and all it's horribleness.

Now as I thought thinking about it I remembered the same HORRIBLE reviews for Speed Racer. And darned if I like the movies any less. They are still two of my favorites of all time.

Why do the critics opinion matter so much to us? Rarely do I see a movie that they recommend and think, "Yes, that was as wonderful as everyone said it was." No, I don't think that. I usually think the critically acclaimed movies are LAME. I like fun movies. Why can't I like movies that I think are fun? What is wrong with that.

So to put this into perspective, I am going to give you a list of other bombed movies. Movies that also had HORRIBLE things said about them.

1.) Nightmare Before Christmas
2.) Monty Python and the Holy Grail
3.) It's a Wonderful Life
4.) Napoleon Dynamite
5.) Tron
6.) Star Wars
7.) Rocky Horror Picture Show
8.) Office Space
9.) Star Trek
10.) Well, I could go on and on...

The point is, why do we let the critics keep us away from movies that we would love? In the end movies critics are just some guy telling us their opinion. Does it have to effect whether the movie becomes a family favorite or not?

10 comments:

Christian Olson said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
marie said...

Your Dad always rates a movie by...if the critics love, stay away from it...if the critics hate it, it's going to be a classic.

Jenna said...

I must have been oblivious to the critics at the time...I remember going to the theater to watch Newsies for the first time, and I came out in love with Christian Bale...and the movie... (:

Kerri said...

My kids LOVE Newsies!

Kari said...

The Nightmare Before Christmas Was liked by critics, but it was considered a box office bomb and has a major following. But it was on a list of lamest movies with a following. It didn't do very well though.

JAMIE said...

Aren't we all critics? Don't we all listen to what friends/family/acquaintances say about films before deciding how much cash to put out for a date night?

No one person will have all the same likes and dislikes. Critics have tendency to look at movies from a very "critical" (go figure) and exploratory view. I rarely agree with them, because I go to movies to enjoy, not to critique. I can find something that I like in almost all films. I'm easy that way.

But I take more stake in what people with my same tastes like when deciding whether to pay for a movie.

Critics enjoy being critical. If they were always pleasant and saw only roses, what would we call them, OPTIMISTS? I think not...LOL

denise said...

I guess I am lucky if I have even heard of a movie lately, let alone to know what the critics said about it.

And I know one demographic that Newsies did not bomb with: Mormons. Mormons still like it and quote it and watch it all the time..

Also, I take issue with whoever said that Nightmare Before Christmas was a lame movie. (:

mathoni said...

I like reading reviews, but I have learned how to interpret whether I will like it, regardless of whether the critic likes it or not. A good critic can tell me what I want to know, and I don't have to agree after I've seen the movie. That's just me.

Christian, while the opening weekend was limited, Nightmare Before Christmas had a wide release weekend earnings of only $8 million dollars. It's estimated budget of $18 million means it fits well into the bomb range, no matter how well the critics liked it. Over its lifetime, Nightmare eventually made money, $76 million. Not bad, but to put this into perspective, Harry Potter and the Halfblood Prince has passed $300 million, and that movie was just released this summer. Nightmare was released in 1993.

Sources:

http://www.boxofficemojo.com/movies/?id=nightmarebeforechristmas.htm

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0107688/business

Kerstin said...

I never could figure out why Newsies didn't do that well when it came out, either.

I was also sad that most of the scenes between the Christian Bale character and the romantic girl interest where cut out.

I can only imagine what happened between them by listening to my soundtrack of the lovey-dovey songs that never made it on screen ("on the rooftop" anyone???)

Christian Olson said...
This comment has been removed by the author.